Plant of the Month: June


by Sue Gray

Thalictrums are a genus in the ranunculaceae family, with approaching 70 species, plus varieties, listed in the Plant Finder.  Crug Farm is particularly noted for them, with many listed in Plant Finder bearing the detail ‘B&SWJ…’ indicating that the plants originate from seed collected by the Wynn-Jones.  I have to admit that I have had one or two such, but have had great difficulty distinguishing them from the more usual varieties of T. delavayi, but that might just be me!  They are such useful plants for the summer garden, with varieties ranging in size from the diminutive T. kiusianum, just a few cms tall but which many people, including me, find very hard to keep, to the statuesque ‘Elin’ or its descendant ‘Anne’, both of which can reach about 2.5m, but do not normally need staking.  Most have flowers of mauve or white, but there are the forms such as T. flavum which bear creamy yellow flowers above grey/green foliage.

Thalictrum isopyroides

Usually the foliage is green or grey/green and, whilst there is a particular species ‘aquilegiifolium’, in general the leaves are aquilegia-like and can be very dainty, resembling Maidenhair Fern, as seen on T. isopyroides or ‘minus’ where there is a variety named ‘Adiantifolium’.


Thalictrum ichangense

However, some varieties have slightly larger, and in the case of T. ichangense, distinctively marked, more heart shaped leaves, which sets off the delicate, fluffy flowers.

Thalictrum delavayi

One of the most often seen species is T. delavayi AGM.  We are familiar with the species name ‘delavayi’ being attached to a number of different plants.  It is derived from Fr Jean Marie Delavay; he was a 19th century French missionary and botanist who spent a lot of time in China from 1867 until his death in 1893.  In 1881 he met Fr Armand David – from whom we get ‘davidii’ – who had made his last plant collecting trip to China in the 1870’s, and who encouraged Fr Delavay to continue collecting plants for the Paris Museum of Natural History.  This he did and he is credited with the introduction of around 1500 new species.

Usually seen in the familiar mauve form, there is a white form, and a number of forms introduced by the Wynn-Jones, also the double form ‘Hewitt’s Double’ with smaller, daintier, flowers.

I find T. delavayi can seed a little in the garden, but is always welcome.

Another species that can self-seed a bit is T. aquilegiifolium.  It can grow to anything from 1m-2m or above and is wonderful for summer colour in shades of mauve and white and, as the name suggests, has the most aquilegia-like foliage.

Thalictrum aquilegiifolium

Many of the recent named forms of thalictrums are varieties of this species, such as ‘Thundercloud’ AGM.  I remember seeing a spectacular plant of ‘Thundercloud’, with wonderfully vibrant flower heads, on one of our garden holidays, but attempts to source and grow said plant have had mixed results! A ‘Small Thundercloud’ has been introduced and the distinction is not always made on plant labels, so, buyer beware!                         

When asking about ‘Thundercloud’ at Dove Cottage, I was told that they felt that ‘Black Stockings’ was actually a better option, and it has certainly become very popular with its black stems.  Sadly mine has suffered a terrible attack of aphids & blackfly this year, which has never happened before, so I have cut it down and am hoping for the best.  Should it not recover, I will definitely want to replace it, as I agree with our friends at Dove Cottage.

Thalictrum ‘Nimbus’

Another relatively new form of T. aquilegiifolium is ‘Nimbus’.  Again, the almost black stems contrast beautifully with the mop of white flowerheads, which are loved by bees.  In his RHS blog, Graham Rice speaks of it as follows: ‘Thalictrums have never belonged to the bestselling rank of hardy perennials, but Thalictrum ‘Nimbus White’ might just change that.’

From the internet I see that there is also a pink form that I will want to seek out, and should it be as good as the white form, will hope to add to the collection!

There are so many species of thalictrum but just to mention two other forms that are rather special.  I have, in the garden, the usual form of T. tuberosum, standing to about 35cms topped with small white flowers.  However, there are some very special forms with much larger flowers.  Those with good memories may remember the plant loaned to us by Bob Brown for our Chelsea display in 2010, which he had bred and named ‘Rosy Hardy’.  He has tried, unsuccessfully, to propagate this plant – if he could do so there would be a long queue of customers, and I would be at the head of it.  It has appeared in his catalogue on occasions, and I have tried to buy it, but the young plants have never survived at the nursery.

Thalictrum diffusiflorum

Another absolute beauty, which I have had twice, but alas no longer, is T. diffusiflorum.  Only growing, in my experience, to about 45cms, the large, intensely blue flowers can almost seem too heavy for the wiry stems.  Elizabeth MacGregor, who sells it from her nursery, recommends keeping it in a pot rather than the open ground; I think the longest I have ever had one is 3 years but, it was beautiful while it lasted!

So, just a small selection of the many forms of this most wonderful and versatile genus, which I hope you will enjoy in your garden.

Kathy’s Quiz: no 9

Every week during the Lockdown, W Yorks HPS member Kathy Howard will produce a horticultural quiz to keep our minds fresh. The answers (no cheating please!) will be attached to the following week’s quiz questions.

For answers to quiz eight, click here

Similar to last week’s but this week it’s songs. Find the missing (horticulturally linked) word to complete the song titles. You can probably tell I was a 70’s baby!

1. Tie a Yellow Ribbon Round The Old — —-              –Dawn feat. Tony Orlando 1973

2. —- The Pink    – The Scaffold 1968

3. Tiptoe Through The ——        –Tiny Tim 1968

4. ——- In The Window             – Travis 2002

5. Green Green —– of Home     – Tom Jones 1966

6. Build Me Up ———   –The Foundations 1968

7. I Heard It Through The ———          – Marvin Gaye1968

8. Love Grows (Where My ——– Goes)           – Edison Lighthouse 1970

9. Bed of —–      – Bon Jovi 1993

10. I Beg Your Pardon, I Never Promised You a —- Garden     – Lynn Anderson 1970

Kathy’s Quiz: no 8 – Answers

Complete the film title

1. Driving Miss Daisy, (1989)

2. Steel magnolias, (1989)

3. A nightmare on Elm street, (1984)

4. The name of the Rose, (1986)

5. The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel, (2011).

6. FernGully : The Last Rainforest (1992)

7. Ladies in Lavender, (2004)

8. The Yellow Rose of Texas, (1944)

9. The Wind in the Willows (1983)

10. Winnie the Pooh and the Honey Tree (1966)

Lockdown Gallery – week 10

May 25th to May 31st

Weather: The last couple of days have been very windy, causing Hardy-Planters to do some desperate staking. The new week, however, brings a return of high pressure – settled, sunny weather is back again

Ann Fritchley is back, explaining a mystery ‘weed’

Kate van Heel is doing very nicely with her Clematis

Judith Ladley has pinned down a Geum

Preston Harrison is amazed at the difference in conditions between February and May, but his garden is flourishing despite the climatic challenge!

Terry Benton has a question of identity for you to solve

Denise Dyson has some stunning colour combinations this week

Lovely to have Maggie Sugden back with us

A friend of mine in London has asked me to identify this plant (the bicoloured one) – I have failed dismally, though I’m sure I’ve seen it before. Can anyone help me (Brian)?

Here’s the latest selection from Judith Edmonds’ garden

Kathy’s Quiz: no 8

Every week during the Lockdown, W Yorks HPS member Kathy Howard will produce a horticultural quiz to keep our minds fresh. The answers (no cheating please!) will be attached to the following week’s quiz questions.

For answers to quiz seven, click here

This week’s quiz is ‘fill in the missing (horticulturally) linked words to complete the film titles.’ 

1. Driving Miss —–, (1989)

2. Steel ———, (1989)

3. A nightmare on — street, (1984)

4. The name of the —-, (1986)

5. The Best Exotic ——– Hotel, (2011)

6. —-Gully : The Last Rainforest (1992)

7. Ladies in ——–, (2004)

8. The Yellow —- of Texas, (1944)

9. The Wind in the ——- (1983) 

10. Winnie the Pooh and the Honey —- (1966) 

Kathy’s Quiz: no 7 – Answers

Who said what?

1. Gardens are not made by singing ‘Oh, how beautiful,’ and sitting in the shade. –Rudyard Kipling

2. My garden is my most beautiful masterpiece. –Claude Monet

3. To plant a garden is to believe in tomorrow. –Audrey Hepburn

4. Almost every person, from childhood, has been touched by the untamed beauty of wildflowers. – Elizabeth Lawrence

5. There is nothing pleasanter than spading when the ground is soft and damp. –John Steinbeck.

6. Isn’t it enough to see that a garden is beautiful without having to believe that there are fairies at the bottom of it too? – Douglas Adams  

7. A weed is a plant that has mastered every survival skill except for learning how to grow in rows. – Doug Larson

8. Plant and your spouse plants with you; weed and you weed alone. – Jean Jacques Rousseau

9. There are always flowers for those who want to see them. – Henri Matisse 

10. The hum of bees is the voice of the garden. ~Elizabeth Lawrence

Lockdown Gallery – week 9

May 18th to May 24th

Weather: Warmer, drier climes have returned. Positively hot in the middle of the week. Last week’s cold is remembered only in a few frost-frazzled leaves

Denise Dyson has a new camera – the Lockdown Gallery is enjoying the fruits!

Judith Ladley is having second thoughts about some Iberis identities!

Maggie Youdan returns with a request for help to name a fern

Judith Edmonds shows how to keep an Osteospermum alive

Terry Benton has been taking some close-ups in Wiltshire

And here are the latest arrivals in the Hackett’s garden in Denby Dale

Kathy’s Quiz: no 7

Every week during the Lockdown, W Yorks HPS member Kathy Howard will produce a horticultural quiz to keep our minds fresh. The answers (no cheating please!) will be attached to the following week’s quiz questions.

For answers to quiz six, click here

This week’s quiz is: Fill in the missing word!

Choose the correct word from this list to complete each quotation

  1. spading
  2. tomorrow
  3. bees
  4. rows
  5. masterpiece
  6. spouse
  7. wildflowers
  8. shade
  9. fairies
  10. flowers

1. Gardens are not made by singing ‘Oh, how beautiful,’ and sitting in the …… –Rudyard Kipling.

2. My garden is my most beautiful …… -Claude Monet

3. To plant a garden is to believe in ….. –Audrey Hepburn

4. Almost every person, from childhood, has been touched by the untamed beauty of ….. – Elizabeth Lawrence

5. There is nothing pleasanter than ….. when the ground is soft and damp. –John Steinbeck

6. Isn’t it enough to see that a garden is beautiful without having to believe that there are ….. at the bottom of it too? – Douglas Adams 

7. A weed is a plant that has mastered every survival skill except for learning how to grow in ….. – Doug Larson

8. Plant and your ….. plants with you; weed and you weed alone. – Jean Jacques Rousseau

9. There are always ….. for those who want to see them. – Henri Matisse 

10. The hum of ….. is the voice of the garden. ~Elizabeth Lawrence 

Kathy’s Quiz: no 6 – Answers

Plants and their uses

1. Which flower did early Christians place around statues of Mary as an offering instead of gold coins and is sold in large quantities in India to make garlands?  Calendula / Marigold.

2. Sloe gin is flavoured using fruits from which shrub? Prunus Spinosus / Blackthorn.

3. The flowers from which plant are used to flavour the sweets gulab jamun and Turkish delight? Rosa / Rose.

4. Which plant produces ‘digoxin’, used to treat heart conditions? Digitalis / foxglove.

5. The candied stalk of which plant is used to decorate cakes and biscuits? Angelica archangelica / Angelica.

6. Which flower is the scent of Christian Dior’s ‘Diorissimo’ based on, and was also included in Kate Middleton’s bridal bouquet? Convallaria majalis / Lily of the valley. 

7. The seed heads of which plant were used to ‘raise the nap’ in cloth making? Dipsacus fullonum / Teasel.

8. Which highly poisonous plant’s Latin name derives from its past cosmetic use in dilating women’s pupils? Atropa belladonna / Deadly nightshade.

9. Cricket bats are traditionally made using wood from which tree? Salix alba var. caerulea / Willow.

10. Which dye was historically extracted from the plant Ysatis tinctoria? Woad

Plant of the Month: May


by Peter Williams

To most people the paeony is ‘that’ plant with the enormous, dark red flowers that they first saw growing in their parent’s, or grandparent’s garden. That plant was almost certainly, the common paeony, Paeonia x festiva ‘Rubra Plena’.

Fig.1 Paeonia x festiva ‘Rubra Plena’ Image HPS library


This lovely old cultivar has been a cottage garden favourite since at least the seventeenth century and has a cast-iron constitution. Provided it is surrounded by other plants to support its oversized flowers, it will exist without care or attention for decades. It is impeccably well behaved and will not leave its post or wander into the company of other plants without an introduction.

The wild and cultivated cousins of the old faithful ‘Rubra Plena’ represent some of the most beautiful hardy plants. For millennia, they have been celebrated in art and culture, and highly valued for their medicinal properties.

Paeonies continue to be important today as garden plants, sources of medicinal compounds, edible oils and as high-value cut flowers. Indeed, the paeony cut-flower business is now a global industry and before the current Corona pandemic, over 100 million cut paeony flowers were sold annually.

The importance of the paeony family is all the more remarkable because it is so very small. It contains just one genus with approximately 36 species.

Until fairly recently, paeonies were thought to be closely related to Glaucidium because of their superficial similarities. However, recent genetic analysis has shown that Paeoniaceae is a distinct family and Glaucidium is a genus in the family Ranunculaceae.

Fig. 2 Plants of similar appearance but members of different families

Paeonies occur naturally in northern temperate zones of Asia, Southern Europe and just two species are found in North America. Three groupings are currently recognised – The largest, the Paeoniae, includes most species of herbaceous paeonies; the Moutan division contains all the shrubby species and Onaepia is composed of the two north American herbaceous species, P. brownii and P.californica. This short article will concentrate upon the herbaceous paeonies from the Paeoniae section of the genus.

Paeonies interbreed easily and very many natural and man-made hybrids exist. Indeed, the RHS Plant Finder has over five hundred entries under Paeonia although the total number of registered cultivars (from all three divisions) is in excess of 3000.

Paeony breeding in Europe became very active from the mid-19th Century when a number of nurserymen, including Jacques Calot and Auguste Dessert in France and James Kelway in Britain, produced scores of stunning new cultivars by crossing the white Chinese species P. lactiflora and the red European species P. officinalis.

The hybrids that resulted generally possessed large, scented, double flowers that lasted longer than the single-flowered species. Early selections like P. lactiflora ‘Duchess de Nemours’ (Calot,1856) and P. lactiflora ‘ Festiva Maxima’ (Miellez, 1851) quickly became very desirable garden plants in the late 1800’s and still are today.

Fig. 3 Two old cultivars that are still popular today Image HPS library

In 1908 French breeder, Victor Lemoine (of lilac and philadelphus breeding fame) produced possibly the most successful paeony of all time, P. lactiflora ‘Sarah Bernhardt’. It was named after the famous actress of the day and cut flowers from this cultivar account for more than half of all cut peony flowers sold.

Fig. 4 The two Sarah Bernhardts

There is a fascinating account of the actress at the Shakespeare blog website

Paeony breeding continued actively throughout the last century in Europe and North America and many notable P. lactiflora cultivars were introduced. ’Jan van Leeuwen’ and ‘Krinkled White’ were bred between the two world wars and ‘Bowl of Beauty’ and ‘White Wings’ in 1949. All are still widely grown and have semi-double flowers that required little or no staking.

Fig. 5 Paeonia lactiflora ‘Bowl of Beauty’ Image HPS library

P. lactiflora ‘Jan van Leeuwen’ featured to stunning effect in Tom Stuart-Smith’s galvanised tank garden at Chelsea in 2008. It was almost the only plant in flower on the stand that celebrated form and foliage effects and nursery firms offering this old variety sold all their stocks on the first day of the show.

Fig.6 Paeony ‘Jan van Leeuwen’ at Mount St John Garden, Felixkirk. The garden was designed by Tom Stuart-Smith

North American paeony breeders have had many successes and large numbers of first-rate cultivars have emerged. The ‘Coral’ series, dating from the mid 1960’s, are the result of crossing the shrubby P. peregrina with P. lactiflora. ‘Coral Charm’ registered in 1964 has the most vibrant coral pink colouration and is very popular both as a garden plant and as a source of cut flowers.

Fig. 7 Paeonia lactiflora ‘Coral Charm’ Image HPS Library

Paeony growing and collecting becomes addictive for some Hardy Planters in much the same way as snowdrops are irresistible to galanthophiles. Individuals often start by growing popular cultivars and then their interests turn to the species and the collection enlarges.

One advantage of including paeony species in a collection is that they generally flower earlier than the hybrids and thus lengthen the flowering season. A number are widely grown including the compact and mound forming P. cambessedesii and P.tenuifolia with fiery red flowers and very finely divided foliage. 

Fig. 8 left, Paeonia cambessedesii and right, Paeonia tenuifolia both images HPS library

P. obovata and P. mascula are elegance personified and may start flowering in early April. Both are worthy additions to any collection. P. mascula the male paeony, was found growing on Steep Holme, the tiny island in the Bristol Channel in the early 1800’s. It was initially thought that it might be a native species but in reality, it was probably introduced for medicinal purposes by the monks of the religious community established on the island in the Thirteenth Century.

Fig. 9 left, Paeonia obovata and right, Paeonia mascula

But of all the species available to enthusiasts, one stands head and shoulders above the rest in terms of popularity. This is pure yellow form of P. mlokosewitschii that is generally known as Molly the Witch. This lovely paeony was initially considered to be a species in its own right but now it is thought to be a sub-species of P. daurica and has been renamed P. daurica subsp. mlokosewitschii. 

Fig. 10 Paeonia mlokosewitschii Molly the Witch

It is found naturally only in eastern Georgia, north-western Azerbaijan and adjacent Russia, and grows in deciduous forests. The red flowered P. daurica has a far wider distribution and hybridizes with the yellow form occur to give variable coloured offspring.

The flowers on P. mlokosewitschii and the other species rarely last for much more than a week and this is why some gardeners feel that they (and all the hybrid cultivars!) are not garden worthy subjects. Paeony enthusiasts clearly would not agree and value fleeting beauty over longevity in terms of the flowers and enjoy many features of the plants in addition to the open flowers. The fat buds that expand at ground level in early spring give rise to highly coloured shoots and neat disease-free foliage that often colours well in autumn.

Fig. 11 P. mlokosewitschii emerging in February and in bud, in early April

Flower buds are visible for weeks before they expand and open – expectant anticipation is part of the enjoyment of growing paeonies.

Fig. 12 P. mlokosewitschii flowers first opening late April
Fig. 13 P. mlokosewitschii in full flower on Mayday 2020

After the flowers fade the furry seed pods (follicles) develop and finally split to reveal the shiny black seeds surrounded by crimson unfertilised ovules.

Fig. 14 P. mlokosewitschii seed pods – mid-August

All paeonies enjoy a sunny aspect but will take some shading. Species like P. mlokosewitschii that originate from open woodland environments probably do best in light shade.

Paeonies are not particular about soil type provided it does not get waterlogged for extended periods. They can be moved far more easily than most traditional gardening authorities would suggest and whilst they will survive nutrient deficiency and neglect, they respond well to feeding. Helpfully, they are not grazed by rabbits or deer because they possess an armoury of toxic chemicals. It is these chemicals that form the active ingredients when paeonies are used in traditional herbal medicines and which are extracted for use in modern pharmaceuticals.

Paeonies also invest resources into the biological control of aphids and other insect pests. They do this by secreting drops of sugary solution on the surface of developing buds. Ants feed on the sugary liquid and in return, keep the buds free from potentially damaging insects.

Fig. 15 Sugary secretions on buds being used by ants

Named cultivars are propagated by division of dormant tubers and is a very straightforward procedure. Established roots are carefully lifted, washed and the thick tubers are severed with a sharp knife. Each root segment with an obvious bud should make a new plant.

Paeonies can also be raised from seed but when this is done the offspring will not of course, be identical to the parent because they have resulted from sexual reproduction. This is often apparent with seed raised P. mlokosewitschii which may have pink or reddish flowers whilst the seed parent’s flowers were clear yellow.

Raising from seed is a very rewarding but rather slow process. When the follicles split to reveal the seeds in late summer, the embryos within are often not mature and will need a few weeks to achieve maturity. When this has occurred the seeds still possess a double dormancy. A warm period is needed to overcome dormancy associated with the emergence of the radicle (root)and the epicotyl (shoot) will not develop until the radicle has reached a critical length and then becomes chilled.  In experiments with P. ludlowii, the radicle had to be at least 6 mm long before it became sensitive to the chilling needed to break hypocotyl dormancy. The low temperature needed for this to occur was 5 degrees C, or lower, for a period of approximately three weeks. In practice this means that seeds sown in autumn or the following spring after formation, do not appear to do anything during the first year. In fact, during this time the radicle will have emerged and when chilled in the second winter, the epicotyl dormancy is broken and the shoot appears. Seeds obtained from seed exchange schemes or bought commercially usually arrive in January. If sown on arrival, the first shoots will emerge above ground approximately 12-14 months later. This germination pattern is exactly what I have observed for a number of species over several seasons.

Fig. 16 Seeds sown February 2015, shoot emergence February2016. Image taken in mid-March

This year, however, I have been surprised to observe that about 20% of the seeds I sowed last autumn have developed shoots this spring.  The seeds were sown fresh from the plants as usual, but weather conditions in autumn must have allowed embryo maturity, radicle emergence and growth to the point where it was large enough to be sensitive to chilling in late winter or spring thus breaking the shoot dormancy. The complex germination requirements have obviously evolved to maximise the establishment of seedlings in the wild.  The best way to mimic these conditions in cultivation is to pot the seeds as soon as possible but leave somewhere where they will experience natural temperature fluctuations. I usually place my seed trays in a shaded and well-ventilated cold-frame.

Fig. 17 Paeony seedling. Image taken 30th April 2020

Seedlings should be potted up annually or planted out into a nursery bed, and they will begin to flower in their third year.

As I write this in mid-May, some of the early flowering species have finished and the large-flowered cultivars have buds showing colour.  The next few weeks will be paeony bliss.

Fig. 18 David Barnes wonderful Paeony-rich garden in Ilkley, June 2016